Texarkana Moonlight Murders

Unsolved 1946 serial murders in Texarkana, United States

The Texarkana Moonlight Murders, a term coined by the contemporary press, was a series of four unsolved serial murders and related violent crimes committed in the Texarkana region of the United States in early 1946. They were attributed to an alleged unidentified perpetrator known as the Phantom of Texarkana, the Phantom Killer, or the Phantom Slayer. This hypothetical suspect is credited with attacking eight people, five of them fatally, in a ten week period. The attacks occurred at night on weekends between February 22 and May 3, targeting heterosexual couples. The first three attacks occurred at lovers' lanes or quiet stretches of road in Texas; the fourth attack occurred at an isolated farmhouse in Arkansas. The murders were reported on nationally and internationally by several publications, and caused a state of panic in Texarkana throughout the summer. Residents armed themselves and, at dusk, locked themselves indoors while police patrolled streets and neighborhoods. Stores sold out of guns, ammunition, locks, and many other protective devices. Some youths attempted to bait and ambush the killer. Investigations into the murders were conducted at the city, county, state and federal level. Over time, there have been shifting opinions by officials over whether the first and fourth attacks were committed by the same perpetrator. The prime suspect in the case, career criminal Youell Swinney, was linked to the murders primarily by statements from his wife plus additional circumstantial evidence. After Swinney's wife refused to testify against him, prosecutors decided against pursuing murder charges. Swinney was convicted on other charges and sentenced to a long prison sentence. Two of the lead investigators believed Swinney to be guilty of the murders. The book The Phantom Killer: Unlocking the Mystery of the Texarkana Serial Murders (2014), written by James Presley (nephew of Sherrif William Hardy "Bill" Presley), concludes that Swinney is the culprit. The events inspired many works, including the 1976 film The Town That Dreaded Sundown. This film is the basis for much of the subsequent myth and folklore around the murders.

The Texarkana Moonlight Murders consisted of four violent attacks which occurred over ten weeks from February to May 1946. The murders occurred in and around Texarkana, twin cities at the border of Miller County, Arkansas, and Bowie County, Texas. All four attacks targeted heterosexual couples in isolated locations, on weekend nights. The attacks took place at intervals of three to four weeks. Investigators speculated that the attacks were the work of an unidentified serial killer.

At around 11:45 p. m. on Friday, February 22, Jimmy Hollis (25) and his girlfriend, Mary Jeanne Larey (19), parked on a secluded road just outside Texarkana, Texas, after having seen a movie together. The lovers' lane was approximately 300 feet (91 m) from the last row of city homes, where present day Central Mall is located. Around ten minutes later, a man wearing a white cloth maskwhich resembled a pillowcase with eyeholes cut outappeared at Hollis' driver side door and shone a flashlight in the window. Hollis told him he had the wrong person, to which the man responded: "I don't want to kill you, fellow, so do what I say". Both Hollis and Larey were ordered out the car, and the man ordered Hollis to "take off [his] goddamn britches." After he complied, the man struck him twice upon the head with a firearm. Larey later told investigators that the noise was so loud she had initially thought Hollis had been shot, but when in fact she had heard his skull fracturing. Thinking the assailant wanted to rob them, Larey showed him Hollis' wallet to prove he had no money, after which she was struck with a blunt object. The assailant ordered Larey to stand, and when she did, told her to run. Initially, Larey tried to flee toward a ditch, but the assailant ordered her to run up the road. Larey spotted an old car parked off the road but found it empty, and was again confronted by the attacker, who asked her why she was running. When she said that he had told her to do so, he called her a liar before knocking her down and sexually assaulting her with the barrel of his gun. After the assault, Larey fled on foot, running a half mile (800m) to a nearby house; she woke the inhabitants and phoned the police. Meanwhile, Hollis had regained consciousness and alerted a passing motorist, who also called the police. Within thirty minutes, Bowie County Sheriff W. H. "Bill" Presley and three other officers arrived at the scene, but the assailant had already left. Larey was hospitalized overnight for a minor head wound. Hollis was hospitalized for several days to recover from multiple skull fractures. Hollis and Larey gave slightly differing descriptions of their attacker: Larey claimed that she could see under the mask that he was a light skinned African American male. Hollis alternately claimed the attacker was a tanned white man, and around thirty years old, but conceded he could not distinguish his features as he had been blinded by a flashlight. Both agreed that the assailant was around 6 feet (2 m) tall. Law enforcement repeatedly challenged Larey's account, and believed that she and Hollis knew the identity of their attacker and were covering for him.

Richard L. Griffin (29) and his girlfriend of six weeks, Polly Ann Moore (17), were found dead in Griffin's car on the morning of Sunday, March 24, by a passing motorist. The motorist saw the parked car on a lovers' lane 100 yards (91 m) south of US Highway 67 West in Bowie County. Griffin was found between the front seats on his knees, with his head resting on his crossed hands and his pockets turned inside out; Moore was found sprawled face down in the back seat. There is evidence that suggests she was placed there after being killed on a blanket outside the car. Griffin had been shot twice while inside the car; both had been shot once in the back of the head, and both were fully clothed. A blood soaked patch of earth near the car suggested to police that they had been killed outside the car and placed back inside. Congealed blood was found covering the running board, and it had flowed through the bottom of the car door. A .32 caliber cartridge casing was also found, possibly ejected from a pistol wrapped in a blanket. No extant reports indicate that either Griffin or Moore was examined by a pathologist. Contemporaneous local rumor said that Moore had been sexually assaulted, but modern reports refute this claim.

At around 1:30 a. m. on Sunday, April 14, Paul Martin (17) picked up Betty Jo Booker (15) from a musical performance at the VFW Club at West Fourth and Oak Street in Texarkana. Martin's body was found at around 6:30 a. m. later that morning, lying on its left side by the northern edge of North Park Road. Blood was found on the other side of the road by a fence. He had been shot four times: through the nose, through the ribs from behind, in the right hand, and through the back of the neck. Booker's body was found by a search party at about 11:30 a. m., almost 2 mile (3 km) from Martin's body. Her body was behind a tree and lying on its back, fully clothed. It was posed with the right hand in the pocket of the buttoned overcoat. Booker had been shot twice, once through the chest and once in the face. The weapon used was the same as in the first double murder, a .32 automatic Colt pistol. Martin's car was found about 3 mile (5 km) from Booker's body and 1.55 mile (2 km) away from his body. It was parked outside Spring Lake Park with the keys still in the ignition. Authorities were not sure who was shot first. Presley and Texas Ranger Manuel T. Gonzaullas said that examinations of the bodies indicated that they both had put up a terrific struggle. Martin's friend, Tom Albritton, said that he did not believe an argument had happened between the victims and that Martin had not had any enemies.

On Friday, May 3, sometime before 9 p. m., Virgil Starks (37) and his wife Katie (36) were in their home on a farm off Highway 67 East, almost 10 mile (16 km) northeast of Texarkana. Virgil was sitting in an armchair reading the newspaper when he was shot twice in the back of the head from a closed double window. Hearing the sound of broken glass, Katie came from another room and saw Virgil stand up, then slump back into his chair. When she realized he was dead, Katie ran to the crank telephone to call the police. She rang twice before being shot twice in the face from the same window. and tried to get a pistol from another room, but was blinded by her own blood. Katie heard the killer at the back of the house and fled out the front door. She ran barefoot across the street to the home of her sister and brother in law. Because no one was home, she ran to neighbor A. V. Prater's house, gasped that "Virgil's dead,” then collapsed. Prater shot a rifle in the air to summon another neighbor, Elmer Taylor, who Prater sent to collect his car. Taylor complied and, along with other members of the Prater family, took Katie to Michael Meagher Hospital (now Miller County Health Unit). Katie was questioned in the operating room by Miller County Sheriff W. E. Davis, who became head of the investigation. Four days later, Davis talked with Katie again, and she discounted a circulating rumor that Virgil had heard a car outside their home several nights in a row and feared being killed. Jackson Neely "Jack" Runnels (1897–1966), the Texarkana chief of police who was among the first called to the scenes of the two double murders. W. E. Davis, the Miller County Sheriff who headed the investigation of the Starks murder. Manuel T. Gonzaullas (1891–1977), a captain in the Texas Ranger Division|Texas Rangers who became the public face of the investigation. He was criticized as a "showman" who presented the work of other officers as his own to the press, and spent a great deal of time with female reporters. Five years after the murders, Gonzaullas left the Rangers to become a technical consultant to the entertainment industry. quotebox|align=right|bgcolor=lavender|width=25%|quote=We want every man and woman in these two counties to recall the dates of these murders and [anyone who] was missing or out of the pocket during those nights. any person with information should act in the interest of self preservation.|source=Presley and Runnels' joint statement when Presley and Runnels called on the public to immediately report anyone who had unexplained absences when the murders occurred. In response to the Griffin Moore murders, police launched a citywide investigation along with the Texas and Arkansas police, the Texas Department of Public Safety (the overseeing agency of the Texas Rangers), the Miller and Cass County sheriffs' departments, and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). Over 200 persons were questioned in the case, and about the same number of false leads were checked. Three people found with bloody clothing were taken into custody; all three were cleared of suspicion. In the Martin Booker case, friends, acquaintances, and several suspects were questioned at by Bowie County investugators who worked in 24 hour shifts. Suspects were brought in from as far away as 100 mile (161 km). Gonzaullas tried baiting the perpetrator by recruiting teenagers to sit as decoys in parked cars while officers waited nearby. Officers also volunteered as decoys, with real partners or mannequins. Following the Booker Martin murders, some officers hid in trees at Spring Lake Park. In the aftermath of the Starks murder, officers from the entire area were called upon to help in the investigation. Blockades were effected on Highway 67 East. Those who had been driving in the area at the time of the slaying, along with several men found in the vicinity, were detained for questioning. By May 5, forty seven officers were working to solve the murder. The unofficial theory for a motive amongst the majority of officers was that of "sex mania", as large amounts of money in the home were not taken, nor was Katie's purse. It rose to $7,025 on the night of the Starks murder

There was some hesitation in linking the Starks murder to the other crimes, because the weapon used was a .22, and Davis believed it was an automatic rifle.

The Griffin Moore murders raised public concerns but were generally taken as an isolated incident, as officials did not publicly connect the earlier Hollis Larey attack to the murders while the Phantom Killer was active. Her high school ended classes early so that hundreds of young people could attend the funerals. For a week police were inundated with reports of prowlers. One officer stated that nearly all of the alarm was the result of excitement, wild imagination, and near hysteria. Previously, it had been normal for houses to be left unlocked. The murders alarmed residents into taking precautions with security: from locking doors to arming themselves with guns; some people nailed sheets over their windows, some nailed windows down and some used screen door braces as window guards. Guard dogs were sought in local want ads. Because citizens were substantially nervous and armed with guns, Texarkana became a dangerous place. When calling on an address, law enforcement officers would turn on their sirens, stand in their headlights, and announce themselves to keep from being shot by a nervous homeowner. Gonzaullas fuelled the hysteria when he announced on May 7 that citizens should "oil up their guns and see if they are loaded" and to "not hesitate" if they feel it necessary to use them. The fear was significant enough to spread to other cities, including Hope, Lufkin, Magnolia, and as far as Oklahoma City, where there were sales spikes for guns and axes. After three weeks without an associated murder, Texarkana's fear began to lessen. The concern lasted throughout the summer and subsided after three months had passed.

The rampant spreading of rumors fed the panic and made the police investigations more difficult. On April 18, Gonzaullas held a press conference to dispel rumors that the murderer had been caught. He stated that the rumors circulating among the public and in the newspapers were "a hindrance to the investigation and harmful to innocent persons." He stressed this again in a radio interview on May 7: "[rumors] only take the officers from the main route of the investigation. It is so important that we capture this man that we cannot afford to overlook any lead, no matter how fantastic it may seem." quotebox|align=right|bgcolor=lavender|width=25%|quote=The people must not become so anxious to rid themselves of the killer that they brand innocent persons as the murderer |source=Sheriff Presley or flown to another jail. The Gazette and News offices were drowned with phone calls, both local and long distance, inquiring about the apprehension of the killer. Presley declared that innocent people were being accused of being the Phantom and asked residents to show more consideration for their fellow citizens. On the night of May 10, Texarkana City Police officers were alerted to a car that had been following a bus. They chased it for 3 mile (5 km) before shooting the tires and arresting C. J. Lauderdale Jr., a high school athlete. When questioned at the station, he explained that he was unaware they were policemen because they were driving an unmarked car. He said he was following the bus because he was suspicious of a passenger that had entered from a private car. He also stated that the man they were hunting was a "cunning individual who would go to all lengths to avoid apprehension." At the Starks murder scene, Presley said, "This killer is the luckiest person I have ever known. No one sees him, hears him in time, or can identify him in any way." Officers have said that the killer is apparently a maniac who is an expert with a gun. Victim and survivor Hollis said, "I know he's crazy. The crazy things he said made me feel that his mind was warped." Tackett was able to locate the former car and arrested Swinney's wife Peggy when she came to retrieve it. Peggy confessed in great detail that Swinney was the Phantom Killer and had killed Booker and Martin. Her story changed in some details across several interviews, and police believed she was withholding information due to fear of Swinney or of incriminating herself. Police were able to independently verify some details of Peggy's confession, such as the location of a victim's possessions where she said Youell had discarded them. There was considerable circumstantial evidence against Swinney,efn|The circumstantial evidence against Youell Swinney included: His wife being in possession of the car stolen the night of the Griffin Moore murders. Swinney repeatedly stated on arrest that "You want [or "got"] me for more than stealing cars." Swinney was never charged with murder and was instead tried and imprisoned as a habitual offender for car theft. Presley reported in his 2014 book that investigators in the Swinney case later said that the sentence was effectively a plea bargain, though the case files indicated no formal agreement. Swinney was apparently concerned about being sentenced to death for the murders, so agreed to not contest the habitual offender charge and in fact tried to plead guilty despite the charge requiring a jury trial.

Henry Booker "Doodie" Tennison was an 18 year old university freshman who died by suicide on November 4, 1948, leaving behind cryptic instructions which directed investigators to a suicide note in which Tennison confessed to the Booker, Martin, and Starks murders.

Ralph B. Baumann, a 21 year old ex Army Air Force (AAF) machine gunner, claimed to have awoken from a fugue state of several weeks on the day of the Starks murder, with his rifle missing. He said that he heard about a suspect matching his description and hitchhiked to Los Angeles, feeling like he was running from murder. On May 23, he told Los Angeles police that he thought he might be the Phantom. "I'm my own suspect," he said. Police arrested him but Gonzaullas stated that several parts of the man's story had little basis in fact. Baumann said that he'd been discharged from the AAF for being a psychoneurotic, and he had previously confessed to killing three people in Texarkana in a period of three days (which did not match the timeline of killings). He had asked about selling the instrument to the store but became evasive and fled from the store manager." Although no saxophone was found in his possession, the police found a bag of bloody clothing in his hotel room. After several days of questioning, the man was cleared as a suspect. Booker's saxophone was located on October 24, six months after her murder, in underbrush near the place her body had been found.

On May 8, it was announced that an escaped German prisoner of war—who was already being hunted as "a matter of routine"—was considered a suspect. He was described as a stocky 24 year old, weighing , with brown hair and blue eyes. He had stolen a car in Mount Ida, Arkansas, and attempted to buy ammunition in several eastern Oklahoma towns. The police kept searching for the POW, but it was said that he had "vanished into thin air."

On May 10, in Atoka, Oklahoma, a man assaulted a woman in her home, ranting that he might as well kill her because he had already killed three or four people, and that he was going to rape her. He then fled. A widespread search for the man included 20 officers and 160 residents. Two days later, police arrested a suspect but did not believe this man was the Phantom. According to the man's story, he could not have been in Texarkana at the time of the Starks murder.

Sammie is a pseudonym given to a longtime Texarkana resident with a good reputation and no criminal record whom the police were reluctant to name as a suspect. He came to attention when his vehicle's tire tracks were found across the road from Martin's corpse. He failed a polygraph test so the police decided to have him hypnotized by psychiatrist Travis Elliott. Elliott concluded Sammie had no criminal tendencies, and learned Sammie had pulled his vehicle to the side of the road in order to urinate before visiting a married woman with whom he was having an affair. Concealing the affair caused Sammie to fail the polygraph test. After police verified the details, they cleared Sammie as a suspect.