Коминас: Панк-рок между Америкой, Исламом и Южной Азией

Punk rock band

The Kominas are a punk rock band formed in 2005 by two Pakistani Americans from Worcester, Massachusetts. In over ten years, the band has experienced a number of line up changes and self released albums.

Their dance oriented sound characteristically blends 1977 punk stylings, with influences from psychedelic rock from around the world (like Türkiye and Iran), Punjabi folk music, surf rock, reggae, disco, and dub. Their songs are often self referential and situational, often challenging listeners to re evaluate their assumptions of what it means to be American, or Muslim, or punk.

In 2005, with the release of just two songs on the internet website MySpace, The Kominas found themselves subjects of national news pieces and film and radio documentaries. Initially self labeled as Bollywood Punk, the band adopted the label "Taqwacore", in reference to a book called The Taqwacores by American novelist Michael Muhammad Knight, which imagines what a would be American Muslim Punk scene would look like. This connection quickly fascinated American and International Media, which led to much being written about this unique example of life imitating art, and many international tours with the author. Many fans of this phenomenon felt that this was a necessary complicating counter narrative to a simplistic and largely Islamophobic post 9/11 American media landscape. They came to renown in South Asia from songs they released in Punjabi, Urdu, and Hindi. Their filmed BBC session where the band covered Bollywood classic "Choli Ke Peeche Kya Hai" especially got the band much positive attention from the Southern Asian and Punjabi peoples, both native and abroad. One of their biggest hits is the song "Tunnnnnn", which is a re interpretation of a classic reggae song; Willie Williams' "Armagideon Time". The lyrics of "Tunnnnnn" are a mashup of English, Urdu, and Punjabi. Its lyrics proclaim (in Urdu): "We will only drink what they drink in Iraq! We will only drink what they drink in Karbala! ", touching upon the subject of the horrific reality of warfare and the bombs which were dropped on those places. "Tunnnnnn" was an instant hit with both Kominas fans and newcomers alike. With the self titled release "Kominas" in 2012, the band has adopted the more Americana rock elements grunge and garage rock in their style and moved away from writing about Muslim centric issues. From 2009–2012 the band toured extensively around America, Canada, and Europe. However, since 2012, the band's output has only been mostly daily missives on their Facebook page, which is more often than not, a commentary on the daily politics of race and religion. The 2021 television series "We Are Lady Parts", written and directed by Nida Manzoor, used the song title "Ain’t No One Gonna Honour Kill My Sister But Me," pulled without permission from or attribution to The Kominas's track "No One Gonna Honor Kill My Baby (but me)" from their eponymous 2011 album. Though their commentary has remained political, many fans feel their music has grown less ethnocentric or religious minded and has taken become more absurdist and nihilistic.

The Kominas use a variety of ways to identify themselves to their Pakistani heritage. For example, they use the word “brown” on Twitter to evoke their racial meanings. The word is used as an identifier of the people of South Asian and Pakistani origins. It connects them to their heritage and to other similar brands and people. The Taqwacore label was another way the Kominas identified themselves. While Taqwacore consists mainly of Islamic punk rockers, bands like The Kominas don’t like how the religious aspect of the label is what people focus on. The band is just as much about the politics of what Taqwacore is. It is about promoting their heritage in a new and different way: through punk rock and through social media. The Kominas and the label Taqwacore brings together people despite the distance that may or may not be between them. They are united through their identity of being “brown,” their love of punk rock, and/or their religious affiliations. The Kominas’ songs and lyrics have a political aspect. They are meant to cause a change in a predominantly white culture. They wish to create safe spaces for people of color listening to their music. In 2020 and 2021 the Kominas held several online fundraisers to benefit the Farmer's Protests in Punjab, India.